More needs to be done to support Black pregnant people in England
The National Disgrace: Black Mothers in England Twice as Likely to Have NHS Birth Investigated
In July 2024, The Guardian reported a shocking statistic: Black mothers in England are twice as likely as their white counterparts to have their NHS birth investigated. This revelation has sparked widespread outcry and renewed conversations about systemic racism in healthcare, particularly within maternity services. The report, based on a comprehensive analysis of NHS data, underscores how Black women face a disproportionate level of scrutiny during childbirth, often leading to invasive investigations into their care, a practice not similarly applied to other groups.
This finding is part of a broader pattern of racial disparities in maternal healthcare, which has long been a contentious issue in the UK. Black mothers are not only subjected to more investigations, but they are also at a greater risk of maternal morbidity and mortality. The findings highlight the need for urgent reform in how maternity care is delivered, addressing issues such as implicit bias, institutional racism, and the need for culturally competent care. In this blog, we’ll explore the wider implications of this disturbing trend, its roots in systemic inequalities, and the organizations supporting Black mothers who may be affected by these challenges.
The Disturbing Reality of Racial Disparities in Maternity Care
The Guardian report highlights the stark difference in how births involving Black mothers are treated compared to their white peers. The term “investigation” in this context refers to the internal review processes triggered when something goes wrong during or after childbirth. These reviews, known as Serious Incident investigations, aim to determine what went wrong and how to prevent future occurrences. While investigations are an essential part of improving care, the fact that Black women are far more likely to be investigated, even in situations where their births were uncomplicated, raises serious concerns about racial bias within the NHS.
The reasons for this disparity are multifaceted, with historical and institutional racism playing a major role. Black women, and particularly those of African and Caribbean descent, have long reported feeling dismissed or ignored by medical professionals during pregnancy and childbirth. Studies suggest that healthcare providers may be less likely to listen to Black mothers' concerns about pain, discomfort, or complications. This lack of trust in the healthcare system can lead to a breakdown in communication, resulting in a higher number of adverse outcomes. When things go wrong, Black mothers are more likely to be blamed or subject to greater scrutiny, despite no greater likelihood of complications than women from other racial backgrounds.
In addition to the increased likelihood of investigations, Black mothers also face significant health risks during childbirth. According to research from the Maternity Review Committee, Black women in the UK are five times more likely to die during or after childbirth than their white peers. These shocking statistics underline the urgent need for targeted interventions to address the root causes of these disparities and provide more equitable care for Black mothers.
The Role of Implicit Bias and Institutional Racism
Implicit bias, the unconscious attitudes and stereotypes that affect decision-making and behavior, is a central factor in these disparities. Healthcare providers may not even be aware that they are treating Black women differently, but the cumulative effect of these biases can lead to unequal care and adverse outcomes. In maternity care, implicit bias might manifest in many ways, from the way a Black woman's pain is perceived or treated to the lack of attention paid to her concerns and symptoms.
In addition to implicit bias, institutional racism within the NHS perpetuates these disparities. Institutional racism refers to the systemic practices and policies that disadvantage certain racial or ethnic groups. In the context of maternity services, institutional racism may manifest as a lack of culturally competent care, an absence of Black midwives or doctors, and a failure to acknowledge or address the specific health needs of Black mothers.
The consequences of this systemic racism are not just theoretical; they are deeply felt by the individuals affected. The stress of navigating a healthcare system that is not equipped to meet their needs can be overwhelming for Black mothers. The fear of being dismissed or treated unfairly can create a hostile environment, discouraging many from seeking the care they need or even speaking up when things go wrong.
Charities Supporting Black Mothers
Given the heightened risks Black mothers face, it is crucial that they have access to resources and support. Several charities and organizations are dedicated to addressing the unique challenges faced by Black mothers in the UK. These organizations work to provide advocacy, education, and direct support, as well as raise awareness of the systemic issues contributing to racial disparities in maternal health.
Tommy’s
Tommy’s the pregnancy and loss charity has a helpline, Tommy's Midwives Helpline for Black and Black Mixed-Heritage women which provides non-urgent care. If you have any concerns about your treatment during your maternity care or any non-urgent concerns about your pregnancy you can book in a call with this line.
Five X More
Five X More are a charity whose mission is to empower, support, and advocate for Black women, in order that they receive equitable and respectful treatment throughout their pregnancies.
Moving Forward: Reforming Maternity Care
The disproportionate scrutiny faced by Black mothers during childbirth is a clear indication that reform is needed within the NHS and across healthcare services. Addressing these disparities requires a multi-faceted approach: from implementing anti-racism training for healthcare professionals to ensuring that policies and practices are inclusive and equitable. Additionally, more support needs to be provided for Black mothers during pregnancy, childbirth, and beyond, ensuring that they feel heard, respected, and safe.
As a society, we cannot afford to ignore the alarming statistics that reveal racial disparities in maternal healthcare. The findings of The Guardian are a wake-up call that must lead to action. For Black mothers in the UK, there is no time to waste. Reform must be immediate, comprehensive, and inclusive to guarantee that no mother is left behind or mistreated due to the color of her skin.
If you are a Black mother or birthing person affected by these issues, reaching out to organizations like Black Mums Up Front, Maternity Action, and The Birth Trauma Association can provide the support, resources, and advocacy needed to navigate the challenges of maternity care. It's time to hold the NHS and healthcare systems accountable, ensuring every mother—regardless of race—has access to the care, dignity, and respect they deserve.
Finally from me
Doula support has been proven to improve outcomes in maternity care. If you are looking for a confident and friendly advocate, who will always treat you and your family fairly, respectfully and in full alignment with your priorities and values take a look at my services or book in a getting to know you call.